Welcome to the Bakery at Butcher's Farm Market

When you walk into Butcher's, the enticing aroma and site of fresh baked pies, cookies, cakes, sticky buns, pull-aparts, whoopie pies and many other sweet temptations will greet you at the door. We use the highest quality ingredients to capture that special flavor as if your Grandma baked it herself.

We bake QUALITY PIES before your eyes!

Our most popular pies include fresh apple, cherry, lemon sponge, shoofly, peach, pecan, coconut cream, raspberry and many other seasonal pies. Available in 9 inch and 5 inch.

Cakes

If you have never tried our chocolate cake, BOY!! are you missing something. Available with peanut butter icing or buttercreame icing.

Cookies - Cookies & More Cookies

Over 10 varieties to choose from. Chocolate chip to snickerdoodles to oatmeal raisin, one bite and you'll fall in love. Cookie trays available for any occasion. Just phone ahead to order.
717-567-3539

Our bakery selection varies daily. If you are looking for something special, we invite you to call ahead 717-567-3539 and reserve that special treat.

We also create Farm Fresh GIFT BASKETS with our homemade baked goods.

Many items baked with sugar substitute available upon request.